The episode of Star Trek we watched made me think of an amusing joke. "Scientists finally discovered how to create humans out of dirt, just like God did when He created Adam. They perfected the process and the day came when the scientists challenged God to a 'man-building' contest. The rules were simple: each would create life from dirt and whoever created the better being would be proved superior. Feeling generous, the scientists allowed God to go first. He created a magnificent man and then split him in half to make a wife for him. God finished and the scientists puzzled over how they could create a better being than the pair God created. they decided to create not just a man and wife, but a whole family. As each of the scientists reached for a handful of dirt and began to mold it, God interrupted and said to the scientists: 'Hey get your own dirt!'"
This really makes me think about men trying to play God. I don't think it will ever get so far as humans being able to create life from dirt, but isn't this the idea when we try to create AI? Especially in the example of Data; he looks and acts like a human and he was created by a man. It seems to me that by trying to create an android, or something similar, humans are trying to become like God. Generally, this is frowned upon by God (look at Lucifer for example) so who is to say that if mankind did manage to create AI, it wouldn't give us what we deserve. Perhaps if mankind does devote themselves to developing a real life Data, a situation similar to that of iRobot would also develop. Maybe that is a good reason to not try to create artificial intelligence.
This really makes me think about men trying to play God. I don't think it will ever get so far as humans being able to create life from dirt, but isn't this the idea when we try to create AI? Especially in the example of Data; he looks and acts like a human and he was created by a man. It seems to me that by trying to create an android, or something similar, humans are trying to become like God. Generally, this is frowned upon by God (look at Lucifer for example) so who is to say that if mankind did manage to create AI, it wouldn't give us what we deserve. Perhaps if mankind does devote themselves to developing a real life Data, a situation similar to that of iRobot would also develop. Maybe that is a good reason to not try to create artificial intelligence.


3 Comments:
Is there a particular problem with "playing God?" The example of Lucifer is not perfect, correct me if I am wrong but was Lucifer's problem more that he refused to worship or that he thought himself better than God. The tower of Babel would be a good analogy, they thought they could best God too.
The idea of "playing God" does not, to me, mandate the idea of trying to usurp or make oneself better then God. I think that God might actually like it when we "play God," perhaps imitation is the sincerest form of flattery? We are creative because He is creative, intelligent because we are of His image. I think that we can "play God" as long as we never think we can best Him.
I think there is a problem with playing God. Lucifer thinking he was better than God is pretty much playing God to me. Also, the people involved in the tower of Babel were punished so how can what they did be seen as a good thing? Eve too sinned when she thought the fruit would give her the wisdom of God. So, yeah, I see that as a huge problem in this issue. However, I also think that God is omnipotent and omniscient and everything else we could imagine, so nothing we create could ever be above Him. With that in mind, I think that no matter how advanced we become we'll still be in God's plan. Even if technology goes too far, God still is in control.
because of these reasons that we would start to have a god complexe i do not belive that humans will ever be able to create AI, i belive that if we ever did we would try and challege God and like the story God would win but put out his wrath
Post a Comment
<< Home